Apartment building in Bay Ridge

458 Senator Street

Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY 11220

1 apartment for rent now · 2 apartments on record

For rent now 1

Off the market 1

Apartments listed here before, with their last asking rent. Open the rent history for every time each was on the market.

  • Apt. 2

    Off the market

    Last asking rent $3,600/month

    Last listed October 2026

    3 beds · 1 bath · 1,050 sq ft

    Rent history 3
    Past asking rents for Apt. 2
    ListedAsking rentResult
    Oct 12, 2026 to Oct 31, 2026$3,600Taken off the market after 19 days
    Aug 19, 2019 to Oct 6, 2019$2,500Taken off the market after 48 days
    May 28, 2014 to Jun 10, 2014$2,000Rented after 13 days

About the building

  • Built in 1899
  • 2 apartments
  • 2 floors
  • No elevator on record

Nearest subway

Bay Ridge Av (R)R

  • 0.1 miles away
  • No step-free access
  • 3 stations within half a mile

School zones

School district 20. From the city’s school zone maps. Zones can change from year to year, so confirm with NYC Public Schools.

How it compares

Per apartment, compared with 159 other apartments LeaseLine listed in Bay Ridge in the last 90 days.

  • Buildings Department complaintsNone in the last 12 months

    None. 75% of Bay Ridge apartments on LeaseLine have none either.

Public records from NYC Open Data and the MTA, as of November 15, 2026. Class C violations are immediately hazardous and class B hazardous. Subway distances are in a straight line, so the walk is a little longer. Records and reviews can be out of date, so confirm what matters to you with the lister.

Location

458 Senator Street, Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, NY 11220

About this page

LeaseLine builds this page from the listings it finds for this building and the city’s public records. Past asking rents are from StreetEasy’s listing history and LeaseLine’s own sightings. Confirm the rent, fees, and availability with each listing’s lister before you apply.

Updated November 15, 2026.