Apartment building in Carnegie Hill
40 East 89th Street
Carnegie Hill, Manhattan, NY 10128
Also 1227 MADISON AVENUE
2 apartments for rent now · 2 apartments on record
For rent now 2
Apt. 5H
For rent$4,125/month
1 bed · 1 bath · 566 sq ft
See the listingRent history 1
Past asking rents for Apt. 5H Listed Asking rent Result Nov 10, 2026 to Nov 19, 2026 $4,125 Seen on the company’s own website by LeaseLine Apt. 12AB
For rent$12,500/month
3 beds · 2 baths · 1,341 sq ft
See the listingRent history 3
Past asking rents for Apt. 12AB Listed Asking rent Result Since Oct 13, 2026 $11,995, listed at $12,500 On the market Aug 23, 2022 to Aug 25, 2022 $8,795 Taken off the market after 2 days Aug 14, 2014 to Jan 25, 2015 $6,495, listed at $7,950 Taken off the market after 164 days
About the building
- Built in 1958
- 94 apartments
- 17 floors
- 2 elevators
- Energy Star score 13 of 100
Nearest subway
86 St (4,5,6)456
- 0.2 miles away
- Step-free access to some platforms
- 3 stations within half a mile
School zones
- Elementary school
- P.S. 006 Lillie D. Blake
- Middle school
- J.H.S. 167 Robert F. Wagner
School district 2. From the city’s school zone maps. Zones can change from year to year, so confirm with NYC Public Schools.
Violations and inspections
HPD counts violations by topic for the whole tax lot, which may include other buildings.
- Mold
- 1 open
- Heat and hot water
- 1 open
- Leaks
- 1 open
- No open violations about
- Lead paint or pests
- Bedbugs
- None in the owner’s 2025 filing
- Facade
- Safe, with repairs to make
Renovation and building permits
- Building permits
- Last issued June 2026. Boiler equipment, general construction, sidewalk shed, structural, and suspended scaffold in the last 5 years
How it compares
Per apartment, compared with 124 other apartments LeaseLine listed in Carnegie Hill in the last 90 days.
- Buildings Department complaintsNone in the last 12 months
None. 66% of Carnegie Hill apartments on LeaseLine have none either.
Public records from NYC Open Data and the MTA, as of November 15, 2026. Class C violations are immediately hazardous and class B hazardous. Subway distances are in a straight line, so the walk is a little longer. Permit dates are when the Buildings Department issued the permit, not when work was done. Records and reviews can be out of date, so confirm what matters to you with the lister.
On Google Maps
Location
40 East 89th Street, Carnegie Hill, Manhattan, NY 10128
About this page
LeaseLine builds this page from the listings it finds for this building and the city’s public records. Past asking rents are from StreetEasy’s listing history and LeaseLine’s own sightings. Confirm the rent, fees, and availability with each listing’s lister before you apply.
Updated November 19, 2026.